YMN The Young Mathematicians' Network
Serving the Community of Young Mathematicians
Sections: Front Page   Career   Diaries   Editors   Work and Family Life   Grad Life   Job Search   Misc   Paths to Math   Research   Teaching   Undergrad Life   Events   Frequently Asked Questions   News
PhD in Math Programs- ultra-competitive? Grad Life

By vizioneer
Posted Sat Jul 22, 2006 at 07:03:17 PM PDT
So I've been looking at programs, admittedly upper-ranked (some middle), and it looks like there's about a 10% acceptance rate going on.

Post a Comment

It seems that a lot of that is due to the no. of funded spots and the no. of applicants. 250 applicants and 20-25 funded spots seems to be a common ratio. The average profile of an admitted student seems to be upper 3's GPA, 80+% GRE Math, 760+ quantitative on the GRE General, good recommendations, and of course some research experience helps (although some have said not necessary for admission).

So what's going on here? Are there that many math zealots at the PhD program gates? Does anyone other than a rabid math student stand a chance?

I guess I'm writing from the viewpoint of having been a bit of an undergrad slacker, who's gone on to a 40ish ranked grad program and earned an MA recently, and who now wants to get into a really good program for a PhD. Some schools I like are AZ, Notre Dame, Emory, Washington Univ. St. Louis, Davis, UT, WA, JHU, MD College Park, etc.

I've queried some of the program's directors, and suprisingly received pretty positive feedback about my background. But, having talked to say others (grad secretaries e.g.), and gotten the average snapshot of an admitted student, I think my chances are not so great.

For my undergrad, it is a C GPA. For my MA, it's a 3.4 GPA. I am studying for the GRE Math now and hope to pull an 85+%. Hopefully this will alleviate the undergrad GPA. I was working full-time in management while doing my MA, and hence it took an extra couple of years to finish. In my grad level core courses I earned B's and B-'s. I have a few A's though. And pretty good recommendations as well. I really came in deficient (obvious from my undergrad GPA) but was told to take grad-level cores right away. Towards the end of my MA, since I was just working on my final project, I decided to take undergrad algebra and analysis and I earned A's and a recommendation from the professor, who got his PhD from Cambridge and is quite published but probably not so active nowadays.

So that's a bit of a snapshot of me- a mixed bag for sure. I am a Native American and I do know there are fellowships open to minorities, but I don't know how much this would help an admission decision. Certainly programs like Iowa are very geared towards this.

Going and taking a year of algebra and analysis at the school I'd want to get into is definitely a way to get in as well, but would be expensive out of pocket and I'd have to work quite a bit to pay rent. Also, despite being told it'd be a way to get in, what if for some reason I didn't get in? LOL.

Anyway, I'm rambling now. I guess I should just maximize my application portfolio and let the chips fall where they may.

So, am I up the proverbial sh*t creek, or is there a chance I could actually get into a good program? I've considered also applying to MS in Applied Math programs for starts, since there are some neat areas such as combinatorial optimization, and math biology (topology and DNA/protein).
< YMC 2006 | School is coming! >
Display: Sort:
PhD in Math Programs- ultra-competitive? | 6 comments (6 topical, 0 hidden)
[new] letters of rec matter lots (5.00 / 1) (#3)
by kroth on Mon Jul 31, 2006 at 07:23:46 AM PDT

I'm not sure exactly how much undergraduate grades count, especially if they were awhile ago and you've completed a masters since then. However I do know for sure if your letters of rec are good that is really important. If you can have someone from your MA write about what you are like as a student now that will help. Math bio is a really hot field right now for reference. I'm not sure how that affects admissions, but it certainly will make finding a job easier. Also knowing what field you want to work in and who you wnat to work with should help your application as well. It is worth applying. Let us know how it all turns out. Kim



[new] Oh Canada Oh Canada (none / 0) (#1)
by vizioneer on Sat Jul 22, 2006 at 11:34:13 PM PDT

Forgot to mention, Univ. British Columbia and Univ. Waterloo seem pretty cool!



[new] SACNAS (none / 0) (#2)
by Vanes63 on Mon Jul 31, 2006 at 07:20:28 AM PDT

Although this does not answer all your questions, I will give you a partial answer to at least one question right now and attempt another answer when I have some more time to sit down at the computer and really give this some time.

Your situation is a lot more common than I think you realize and yet still many people get their Ph.D's lol. So I think you are in a good boat, but working hard at making good --> better never hurt anyone.

"I am a Native American and I do know there are fellowships open to minorities, but I don't know how much this would help an admission decision. Certainly programs like Iowa are very geared towards this."

The Society for the Advancement of Chicanos and Native Americans in Science [SACNAS] can help you find some programs that are geared towards minorities, like Iowa, and can provide some guidance and support through one of their many mentor programs.

Mind you, there are not an abundance of mathematicians on the site (I am Mexican-American/Native American and am pretty afraid of "not fitting in" to a program, so I usually try to find people I can get along with and sympathize), but the National Conference is a blast and I would 100% recommend going. It is in October, so that presents a problem in terms of keeping up with work, but they have workshops on finding fellowships, math institutes near the beginning of the conference, many mixers, excellent speakers during the meals, and just a treasure-trove of experiences you can find no where else.

The exhibits are also a must-see because not only are prospective departments there, looking for students, but research opportunities, graduate students and professors.

I believe you can really find out if a program fits you while you are there. So check it out and see if SACNAS is a good fit for you. I found it gives me an outlet and a good refresher during the school year. It looks like I will not be able to attend this year (unfortunately) because I will be starting my first semester of an MS program, but I will try really hard to go next year so I can present a talk.



  • Scholarships by Vanes63, 07/31/2006 07:24:18 PDT (none / 0)
[new] thanks (none / 0) (#5)
by vizioneer on Mon Jul 31, 2006 at 02:19:21 PM PDT

for the replies! I am going to get some feedback from Univ. of AZ whom I applied to recently but decided to wait until the Fall after my GRE Math to have them consider my application. The advice about networking and recommendations will be useful when it comes time, and I will definitely keep everyone interested abreast about what happens. I think, given what say Univ. of WA and AZ have said though, that the shot is there and I just need to stay spot-on until application time! Now, the really hard part is finding what one wants to specialize in and which programs are offering it. :P



[new] input (none / 0) (#6)
by vizioneer on Mon Aug 07, 2006 at 10:02:38 AM PDT

So I got some feedback from Univ. of AZ. The director of the grad program said that if I take another grad course locally and do well with a reference, I could start in the Spring. Of course, this is nice, but will be added to the stack of applications I will complete this Fall after taking the GRE Math. I'm feeling a bit old in my early 30's to be taking the time and pains to do this, but I guess it's a decision I've made. I like the idea of a life of effecting change and educating people at a univ.. I'm sure the extra course (perhaps applied combinatorics) will help my other applications as well.



PhD in Math Programs- ultra-competitive? | 6 comments (6 topical, 0 hidden)
Display: Sort:
Menu
create account
FAQ
Search
Recent Comments

Login
Make a new account
Username:
Password:

Related Links
Also by vizioneer

SourceForge Logo Powered by Scoop
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest

create account | faq | search