Beating them to the Punch
Emil Volcheck's recent piece on "getting scooped" reminded me of my
situation as a graduate student years ago. Back in '92, I was working in
quantum groups, mostly reading in the area and also attending important
conferences in ring theory and Hopf algebras. One of my advisor's
colleagues was working with another colleague on an extension of an
important construction of a particular bialgebra that my advisor said
would be good for me to pursue as the centerpiece of my Ph.D.
dissertation.
In the summer of '92, my advisor and I attended a conference on Hopf
algebras hosted at DePaul. Many of the "big guns" interested in Hopf
algebras and quantum groups were there, including the gentleman who was
also interested in the above-mentioned extension. My advisor said I might
have three weeks to produce the extension, as the hot interest in the area
meant that someone else would certainly do it and get it in print fairly
quickly. No pressure there!!
The fall 1992 semester got underway, and I was busy trying to produce
the result; a misunderstanding on my part cost me some valuable time in
obtaining the generators and relations for the desired bialgebra. My
advisor's colleague and his collaborator basically had much of the work
done themselves, but they graciously gave me "first dibs" on the work if I
could get it done by Dec. 31, 1992. It took a bunch of work, and a little
luck, but I was able to fax them my results by Dec. 30th to beat their
deadline. Soon after, I received a nice letter from one of them
congratulating me on the work, and granting me permission to use it in my
dissertation and then publish the results. All's well that ends well, as
they say!
Kevin Charlwood, Washburn University
E-mail: kevin.charlwood@washburn.edu