YMN The Young Mathematicians' Network
Serving the Community of Young Mathematicians
Sections: Front Page   Career   Diaries   Editors   Work and Family Life   Grad Life   Job Search   Misc   Paths to Math   Research   Teaching   Undergrad Life   Events   Frequently Asked Questions   News
Display: Sort:
Lessons Learned from Getting Scooped | 4 comments (4 topical, 0 hidden)
[new] getting scooped (none / 0) (#1)
by Anonymous Hero on Thu May 01, 2003 at 07:53:02 PM PDT

Hi everyone,
Here is my story.
My PhD adviser is a famous mathematician from a
foreign country. He's got very few connections in
the US and does not have any collaborators,
as far as I know. The range of problems that he
is interested in is rather broad.
I was perfectly happy with that.

***
He had me work on
a conjectural statement connected to a famous
conjecture of his.
He explained me that the existing ideas are not
sufficient, and it would be nice if I can learn
some tools from a related field. Then I should
try to apply ideas from that area to my problem.
I spent about two years learning the new tools that
he was suggesting and in the meantime I had also
proved some nice (small) result unrelated to his
problem.  
He told me that it would be about 25% of my thesis.
I was perfectly happy with that.

***
Then I started working on the suggested problem
and solved it. Initially he said that would be my
thesis. Then I wrote the authors of the conjecture
and found out that one of them had the problem solved
(about 4 months ahead of me)
and his preprint was already submitted to a journal.

***
As I said before, my adviser does not talk to anybody
and consequently he was not even aware of the status
of my problem. When I told him, he changed his mind
with respect to my graduation and gave me one more
year to solve some other question. He didn't give
me a specific one, realizing that I would have
little time to solve it.

***
Honestly, I was thinking of changing fields
at that point. Finally, the summer was a good time
for me to rethink my options and decided that
I could still do something. And I solved some
other small question and graduated.

***
Unfortunately, mathematics is a field where the
big fish eats the small fish. My advise for you,
if you happen to be in graduate school and read
this: don't choose advisors who are newcomers to
the US (I feel sorry to say that, I'm an international
person myself), are less active or have very few
connections. You may end up in the role of the small
fish.

***

Good luck to you all!



Lessons Learned from Getting Scooped | 4 comments (4 topical, 0 hidden)
Display: Sort:

Menu
create account
FAQ
Search
Recent Comments

Login
Make a new account
Username:
Password:

SourceForge Logo Powered by Scoop
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest

create account | faq | search